Magic Basketball Mailbag, 9/27/10 | Magic Basketball



Sep 27

Magic Basketball Mailbag, 9/27/10


Photo by Marc Serota/Getty Images

Here’s another installment of the Magic Basketball Mailbag.


Will the Magic make an offer for Melo after all?

Most likely, no.

If it hasn’t happened now, then it probably won’t happen.

I just had a debate with some Lakers fans. One of them claims that we have no defense against the Heat. What’s your take?

Dwight Howard thinks otherwise.

Having the two-time Defensive Player of the Year as the anchor of the defense will help the Orlando Magic against the Miami Heat and slow them down a little bit, but it’s not entirely clear if he alone is enough to stop them. Yes, the Magic have a bevy of perimeter defenders but none of them have proven that they can stop either LeBron James or Dwyane Wade, or even slow them down at all.

James, Wade, and Chris Bosh have been Magic-killers for years. This is nothing new and when looking at the matchups defensively, even with Howard in the paint to help discourage James or Wade from attacking the basket at will, it’s doubtful that it will be enough. That’s what’s frightening about this matchup. Orlando has almost no choice but to single-cover James, Wade, and Bosh at times. Who stops them?

Maybe Bosh can be contained, but what about James and Wade?

Let’s put it this way.

In 2009, the Magic led the NBA in defensive efficiency yet were unable to effectively defend James, Wade, and Bosh individually on their respective teams.

James eviscerated Orlando’s defense in the Conference Finals, averaging 39 points, eight rebounds, and eight assists per game. That’s not even including James’ regular season meetings, mind you.

Wade, infamously, scored 50 points in a loss during a regular season game and in four meetings, averaged an obscene 38 points per game on a .579 True Shooting percentage.

As for Bosh, he averaged 24.5 points per game on a .622 True Shooting percentage — including a 40-point outburst in one meeting.

And remember, this was when they were the primary focus of the Magic defensively.

Yes, there’s going to be a redistribution of shots and possessions but if James, Wade, and Bosh were able to accomplish these feats by themselves, it’s scary to figure out what they’ll do as a tandem.

For example, the Heat could employ the Charlotte Bobcats’ strategy of going right at Howard in the paint and draw fouls on him. If Miami were to succeed in that philosophy, have mercy on Marcin Gortat because he’s going to be left on an island.

With the new contract, will Redick play more?


It wouldn’t be a surprise to see Redick average more than 25 minutes a game, given that head coach Stan Van Gundy has stated he’s more than willing to pair Redick and Vince Carter at the wing positions since that’s an alignment that has had success.

For a year or two, Mickael Pietrus was considered by some as the sixth-man specialist for the Magic. But now that role is firmly in the grasps of Redick, who’s proven to be an excellent role player. It’ll be interesting to see how much Redick’s workload increases this season.

And remember, there’s also the possibility that Redick becomes the long-term starter at shooting guard in 2012 if Carter does not return.

I really don’t think, or probably even want this to happen, but wouldn’t it be possible to put together attractive packages for BOTH CP3 and Melo? The Hornets would be interested in Nelson and Carter, while the Nuggets would be looking for a package around Bass and Gortat.  Now, I have always had Bass going to the Hornets to offset Okafor’s contract, but are there groupings of players that would work?

Wait, why wouldn’t you want it to happen? Moving on.

No, it’s not possible.

Just to get Chris Paul, the Magic would definitely have to give up more than Nelson and Carter.

Ryan Anderson or Brandon Bass, as well as Gortat would have to be included in the discussion as well. In that scenario, there would be no pieces left for a hypothetical deal with the Nuggets (that would interest them, to be specific). Orlando has assets but they don’t have enough of them to acquire two players of Paul’s and Anthony’s caliber.

It would have to be one or the other, not both.


Thanks for the questions!

If you have a question for the mailbag, you can reach me at eddy.rivera7 [at] gmail [dot] com

Eddy Rivera
Eddy Rivera

@Ron Burgundy

You totally missed the point of that comment. I was referring to their individual success against the Magic, not the teams they were playing on.

Yeah, the better team will prevail and it might be the Heat.

@Billy (slickw143)

Anyone who underestimates the Heat is a straight up idiot.


don't worry there is nothing to be afriad doesnt matter how much talent u think the heat have ....the fact of the matter is the best team will win and has a magic fan we have nothing to fear but ourselves and thats just simply how it dont be scared

Billy (slickw143)
Billy (slickw143)

@Ron Burgundy
I'm as true of a Magic fan as there is, but I'm not blind. The Cavs-Magic series was very close despite what people remember with basically LeBron being the entire team. The Heat beat the Magic twice last year behind Wade and mostly JUCO players. Giving either one of them someone like Bosh as a second banana is pretty nuts. Giving them each other with Bosh as a third banana is just... bananas.

It's foolish to not be afraid of what they're capable as a team if outside factors don't bring them down. Hell, I'm afraid of what Mike Miller's going to do while standing out behind the three point line wide open every possession.

Ron Burgundy
Ron Burgundy

What were the Cavs, Heat, and Raptors records while they were "Magic killers." Usually a killer is someone who wins, not scores a ton of points in a loss. Ray Allen was a Magic Killer with the Bucks, Tim Duncan and Yao Ming were always Magic killers, Dwade is a Magic killer, but things will be different with LeBron, and Chris Bosh on the floor. As for the aforementioned former Cav and Raptor, THE MAGIC OWNED THEM!!! ALMOST EVERY GAME THEY PLAYED. NO TRUE MAGIC FAN IS SCARED OF THE HEAT, WE KNOW THE BETTER "TEAM" WILL PREVAIL.