Photo by Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images
Six months ago, you would have been hard-pressed to find a lot of people within the Magic fan base that did not want Dwight Howard’s jersey retired. Yes, at that point in time, Dwight had already made known his desire to be traded, with the Brooklyn Nets at the top of his wish list.
But this was before Dwight chose to opt in, then opt out, then opt in again at the March 15 trade deadline when the Orlando Magic needed to know from him whether he was going to waive his early termination option and stay for one more year beyond the 2011-2012 season (backing away from their original stance of wanting to know if he was going to commit long-term) or be forced to trade him.
This was also before Stan Van Gundy, on April 6, spilled the beans and let the public know before the Magic’s regular season game against the New York Knicks (which aired on TNT, heightening already-heightened drama surrounding the team) that Dwight wanted him fired.
In other words, Dwight hadn’t turned nearly every Magic fan against him just yet. Many of them were sympathetic to him wanting to join a better team, in fact.
Fast-forward to today and if asked the question, “would you retire Dwight’s jersey?” a majority of the Magic fan base would answer “no.” That’s because all the goodwill that Dwight built up over the years in Orlando was destroyed in a matter of months because he was indecisive about wanting to stay or leave, all the while undermining Van Gundy. But when stepping back and taking an objective look at Dwight’s career with the Magic, should he be denied the honor of having his jersey retired?
With the help of a jersey retirement formula created by Ben Golliver of Blazer’s Edge, we can come up with a verdict.